Identify stronger and weaker evidence to support a claim

Key notes :

Understanding Claims:

  • A claim is a statement or assertion that is open to challenge and requires evidence to be supported or refuted.
  • In writing, the claim is typically the main argument or thesis the writer is making.

Types of Evidence:

  • Stronger Evidence:
    • Facts: Reliable, verifiable information (e.g., statistics, scientific data).
    • Expert Opinions: Insights or views from individuals with expertise in the field (e.g., academic researchers, professionals).
    • Examples and Case Studies: Real-world examples that clearly illustrate the point.
    • Logical Reasoning: Well-thought-out explanations that make sense based on the evidence.
  • Weaker Evidence:
    • Personal Anecdotes: Personal stories or experiences, which may not be generalizable.
    • Opinions: Individual views or beliefs without sufficient support.
    • Emotional Appeals: Arguments based on emotion rather than logic or fact.
    • Unverified Information: Data or facts that cannot be independently confirmed or are from unreliable sources.

Evaluating Evidence:

  • Credibility: Is the source of the evidence trustworthy?
  • Relevance: Does the evidence directly relate to the claim being made?
  • Sufficiency: Is there enough evidence to back up the claim? One piece of evidence may not be enough.
  • Accuracy: Is the evidence correct and up-to-date?

Balancing Evidence:

  • Stronger evidence helps to build a convincing argument and persuade the audience.
  • Weaker evidence may weaken the credibility of the claim, leading to a less persuasive argument.

Examples of Strong and Weak Evidence:

  • Strong Example: “Research from the American Heart Association shows that 30 minutes of exercise daily reduces heart disease risk by 40%.”
  • Weak Example: “I’ve heard that exercise is good for you.”

let’s practice!